Intellectual Property Law

When market entry fee part of damages for patent infringement, permanent injunction inappropriate

By McKee, Voorhees & Sease, P.L.C.

In a recent decision, the Federal Circuit affirmed a finding of infringement of a patent relating to the detection and classification of Hepatitis C Virus, but remanded the case for a determination of anticipation. 

In arguably the most interesting aspect of the decision, the court vacated the permanent injunction entered against the defendant.  The plaintiff asked for and was awarded damages to compensate for the amount the defendant would have had to pay the plaintiff for a "market entry fee."  As a result, the court reasoned the plaintiff could not assert that it would be irreparably harmed by future sales by the defendant, having already been compensated for the harm caused by the defendant's entry to the market.  The court therefore instructed the district court on remand to determine the amount of royalty due on the defendant's compulsory license under the patent going forward.

The court briefly mentioned the issue of willful infringement after In re Seagate Technology, LLC, but only noted that there was no evidence of objective recklessness by the defendant and therefore the finding of no willful infringement was appropriate.  The court also gave a reminder to parties and lawyers of the potential consequences when being too cavalier toward obligations under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.  As explained in the court's footnote 4:

This case aptly demonstrates the pitfalls of playing fast and loose with rules of discovery. Conclusory expert reports, eleventh hour disclosures, and attempts to proffer expert testimony without compliance with Rule 26 violate both the rules and principles of discovery, and the obligations lawyers have to the court. Exclusion and forfeiture are appropriate consequences to avoid repeated occurrences of such manipulation of the litigation process.

[More]

Full post as published by FileWrapper on January 21, 2008 (boomark / email).