Home -> Law Blog Directory -> Academic Blogs -> Legal Theory Blog

Academic

: Legal Theory Blog

Ribstein on Subramanian, Hersovici, & Barbetta on Preemption of Delaware's Antitakeover Statute

By Lawrence Solum

Larry E. Ribstein (University of Illinois College of Law) has posted Preemption as Micromanagement (Business Lawyer, Vol. 65, p. 789, 2010) on SSRN. Here is the abstract:

Guhan Subramanian, Steven Herscovici & Brian Barbetta, Is Delaware?s Antitakeover Statute Unconstitutional? Evidence from 1988-2008 , 65 BUS. LAW. 685 (2010) (?SHB?), argues that the constitutionality of the Delaware takeover statute is ?up for grabs? because it denies bidders the ?meaningful opportunity for success? three Delaware district court opinions require to avoid preemption by the Williams Act. However, this comment on SHB argues that, even assuming the applicable federal cases might be construed to support SHB?s conclusion, courts almost certainly would not follow this approach once they saw, with the aid of SHB?s analysis, the extent to which it requires courts to micromanage state corporate law. Moreover, from a policy standpoint, this micromanagement could have a significant negative effect on the development of state law. In short, rather than providing an argument for preempting the Delaware statute, SHB?s analysis demonstrates why it is important to avoid this result.

Highly recommended.

Full post as published by Legal Theory Blog on June 18, 2010 (boomark / email).